Boycott Kathy Mattea, Patti Loveless and Dave Matthews
by Michael Browning, Managing Editor
23 months ago | 1881 views | 7 7 comments | 9 9 recommendations | email to a friend | print
West Virginia native Kathy Mattea, who was once a country music star, is trying to get back into the limelight by waging war on coal mining.

And she’s enlisted the help of several other rock, pop and country stars, including one from nearby Pike County, Ky., in her war on coal.

Mattea, in an exclusive interview with The Logan Banner recently, said she wasn’t against mountaintop removal mining, after she’d taken an anti-surface mining stance months earlier.

She said in the interview that she had seen the situation from both sides — she flew over a reclamation project and cried over the loss of the mountain, but then spent some time at a coal mine and understood the plight of the miners.

Now, however, she has turned back to her anti-mountaintop removal stance and will perform at a Nashville fundraising concert featuring Dave Matthews and others, that is being sponsored by the Natural Resources Defense Council to fight mountaintop mining in Appalachia.

The May 19 concert at the Ryman Auditorium, called Music Saves Mountains, will also include performances by Emmylou Harris, Patty Griffin, Buddy Miller, Patty Loveless and Kathy Mattea.

A news release Friday announcing the concert and lineup said net proceeds will go to pass laws to end the practice.

Tickets cost $45, $75 and $95.

Hopefully, no one will show up for the show, but there will be plenty of the great-unwashed environmentalists (or, as Staff Writer J.D. Charles calls them, “environmentalcases”) there to cheer the anti-coal traitors on.

What’s really ironic is that the concert is being held in Nashville, far away from any mountaintop removal mining. Why not hold the concert here, Kathy? Because she knows they would be run out of the state for taking part in such an event.

Shame on you, Kathy Mattea and Patti Loveless, who comes from Elkhorn City, Ky., just across the river in Pike County, Ky. (Loveless is no stranger to being ashamed of where she’s from: She graduated from Elkhorn City High School in the tiny town, but claimed the more famous and politically-correct city of Pikeville as her hometown)

Both Mattea and Loveless are from coal-producing states and look at what moving a mountain — or a river, as they did in Pikeville to build roads and provided flat land for a cinema complex, the Hall of Justice (Pike County’s courthouse and jail) and other businesses and facilities — has done for their states.

We, here in southern West Virginia, wouldn’t have a wood products park on Holden Mountain, nor the Fountain Place Mall if it weren’t for post-mine reclamation. As anyone who lives here can see, we don’t have an abundance of flat lands, like there are in Mattea’s native Putnam County.

And that’s not even counting the jobs that mountaintop mining has provided for our people here in Coal Country.

Williamson, in Mingo County, is called the Heart of the Billion Dollar Coalfields, and a lot of that is due to surface mining.

We're sure that a lot of those coal miners probably have spent coal mining dollars and cents on Mattea's and Loveless's CDs and concert tickets.

But, instead of thanking the coal miner for those hard-earned dollars, they are biting the hand that has fed them for so many years.

Maybe it's time the coal miners and their families and friends spoke with their wallets by boycotting these musicians and singers, like Mattea, Loveless, Dave Matthews, Emmylou Harris, Patty Griffin, Buddy Miller and others who take up the environmentalists' war on coal.

They site atop their ivory towers and tell the world how bad coal mining is when most of them don't know anything at all about surface mining and its benefits. All they see if one or two mountains gone and flat land in their place. Hey, if you want to see plenty more mountains, make a trip into West Virginia and visit with the people here in Coal Country, where coal is the lifeblood of our people and our economy.

We see plenty of singers and actors going to foreign countries for their various causes. But, we hardly ever see any come to West Virginia to see the struggles of coal miners and their families and communities in which they live.

All of these so-called-stars need to come to West Virginia and spend a day in a coal town like Logan or Williamson and see just how wrong they are to attack coal.

Coal is vital to our economy here in West Virginia. And surface mining is a big part of that.

I, for one, will never buy any CDs or songs by Mattea, Loveless nor any of the others who have taken an anti-coal stance and I hope more and more people do the same.

Kathy Mattea lied when she said in the recent interview that she isn’t against coal mining.

Now, her true colors are showing bright and clear and everyone whose lives are affected by coal mining needs to take a stand against her, the same way she’s taking a stand against coal mining and its many employees.

Boycott their music!

Speak with your wallets!

Take away their cashflow and see how quickly they change their minds and turn and embrace coal mining.
Comments
(7)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
wv-soul
|
March 10, 2010
It is unfortunate that any paid "journalist" isn't required to do a little research and/or at least know what he or she is talking about before being permitted to publish anything. Mr. Browning is off the mark on so many aspects of his blathering that it would take too much effort to correct him on every point. Mr. Browning is completely wrong about Ms. Mattea's motives and character, and he misrepresents even what she said to the Logan Banner. At best, this publication is just a rag without journalistic integrity, and thus not worthy of a reader's time. At worst, Mr. Browning should be held accountable for his irresponsible statements. Libel, anyone?
eastrivermountain
|
March 09, 2010
Kudos to you, Mr. Browning.

Coal mining accounts for about half of all "surface" mining: extraction of sand, gravel, stone, and clay accounts for another 35%, and phosphate rock for about 5%, with all metallic ores accounting for about 13%. (1)

Are these singers trying to stop production in those industries, too?

Also, consider the comments on this blog: (http://blog.euci.com/?p=112) where the writer notes that many times those who represent environmental groups simply do not have their facts in order...in part, the writer says, "They rarely have done their homework when considering major energy concerns. For example, the need for base load electricity, the costs of electricity transmission over great distances, or the impact of sporadic interruptions of renewable sources of generation. When they make statements that don’t reflect the critical considerations utilities, regulators, and other energy professionals face every day, they sound worse than politicians trying to appease everyone and lose credibility." ....

In addition to these singers, the debate is perpetuated by many who do not live in the Appalachian Mountains, including: Robert F. Kennedy Jr. whose prosperity is linked to companies like BrightSource—currently developing competing solar technologies (2)—and groups like the Sierra Club headquartered in San Francisco, Calif., that calls coal “dirty.” In fact, as coal usage has increased, flu gas pollutants have decreased exponentially due to improvements in technology.

How will the development of these sites on "federally owned land" (I think that means OUR land...developed with OUR TAX DOLLARS), affect the environment? BrightSource Energy (3) proposes to develop 5,130 acres with $1.4 billion (that's with a "b") "loan guarantee" from the Energy Department to "create 86 permanent jobs." WooHOOO! Let’s all move to the Mohave Desert! Oh, wait a minute, there’s a controversy there, too as locals try to protect a species of tortoise that may be endangered.

Let’s just hope that hard-working coal miners and the families they support don’t end up on the endangered species list.

(1) (http://science.jrank.org/pages/4358/Mining-Surface-mining.html#ixzz0hER7Cw7V)

(2) (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/02/22/AR2010022204891.html)

(3) http://articles.latimes.com/2009/sep/18/business/fi-solar18

ausurfer
|
March 08, 2010
I've never cast my eyes on a more biased piece of "journalism" in all of my life. Shame on you for attacking and smearing people who care about the environment more than the likes of you who seem hell-bent on making more $, despite the obvious horrific impact on the countryside.

Kathy Mattea & co are true American heroes...because they are willing to stand up to the coal companies who seem adept at getting govt officials on side.
DaveH8787
|
March 05, 2010
The glaring disregard for all life on the planet and our inability as co-inhabitants to respect and live harmoniously is a position that will surely change as the pain of staying where you are gets greater than the pain of letting go of your egoic identity which you cling to so desperately. I hope that you will find some opening in your consciousness that will allow you to rise up to a new and healthier perspective.
MatteaFan
|
March 05, 2010
Folks, Kathy Mattea is not against coal mining. What she is really FOR is peaceful, civil discussion about common problems. She is for miners and she is for families who live in the shadow of the mines. She is a warm and decent person. Boycotting her music won't do much one way or another, and everyone is entitled to their opinions, of course. But I think we should try to understand what her message really is. Here's a short video clip that gives an idea of it.

http://tinyurl.com/ye7jaqc

Thanks
Bruno13
|
March 04, 2010
Mr. Browning is on another rampage attacking anyone standing up for decency, clean water, and justice. I'm glad these singers are trying to help out those of us who live here and have to put up with coal industry attacks. But I'm glad this time Mr. Browning is asking his coal cult followers to vote with their wallets rather than their fists or bullets.
dollupone
|
March 03, 2010
To the managing editor Michael Browning,You can't tolerate anyone who disagrees with you. Maybe these musician and singers can see something about mountain top removal that you can't. There is no one so blind,as he who will not see. Who do you think will build on those rocks left behind?

Trees can't grow without fertile soil.Fish can't live in toxic water. Wild animals can't feed where there is nothing to feed on. It takes certain elements in soil and trees for gen seng and herbs to grow in shaded areas. Wild mushrooms take a certain kind of soil to grow in. People need clean water to drink. You can't grown a mountain back that you destroyed. Who in their right mind would build on that place where a mountain used to be? The land will be setteling for years. If you build a concrete foundation on it,it will crack. What are you going to build on it,a golf course that is toxic?Of all the mountains removed only 5% of the land has ever been used. Who owns West Virginia? It sure isn't the people who reside there? It is the millionaire coal companies and gas well companies. When it is all over with the coal companies and gas company employees will be gone. Who will be the last person out? Maybe you when you get your pension and retire to Florida. I am going to make sure I buy Kathy Mattea's cd's because she loves the mountains and she didn't forget where she came from.It will take 100 years for the top soil to came back. Who is going to living there ?
Weather
Sponsored By:

Lottery
Sponsored By:

Stocks
Sponsored By:


featured businesses
Gasoline Prices
Sponsored By:

Recipes
Sponsored By: