Tenn. paper blasts area miners for boycott
by MICHAEL BROWNING, Managing Editor
3 months ago | 1063 views | 4 4 comments | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print
A Tennessee newspaper in a highly-visited tourism area has blasted two Logan County officials and Appalachian miners for a boycott over a Tennessee senator sponsoring a bill to stop mountaintop mining.

U.S. Sen. Lamar Alexander recently sponsored legislation that would ban coal companies from doing mountaintop removal mining.

The Mountain Press newspaper published in Sevierville and serving the Pigeon Forge, Gatlinburg and Smoky Mountains areas, in an editorial in its July 23 edition, blasts Appalachian miners for boycotting any vacations planned for Tennessee.

The editorial is titled “A miner detail” and has a subhead that reads “Alexander shouldn’t let threat of boycott stop his push for ban on mountaintop mining”.

Here is the editorial in its entirety:

“Sevier County is a welcoming place. Any tourism community has to be. We want people coming here from all states, other countries, with or without children. We want them to stay as long as they can and enjoy our sites and attractions.

“There is a segment of society that apparently won’t be visiting us any time soon. Some Appalachian coal miners are refusing to vacation in Tennessee because of a stand taken by U.S. Sen. Lamar Alexander on the issue of mountaintop removal.

“Alexander is sponsoring legislation that would bar coal companies from blasting away mountaintops to unearth coal and dumping dirt, rock and trees into the valleys beneath. There are many people who make their living doing such things, and because Alexander is sponsoring the bill, they feel the best way to retaliate is not visit his state and spend money.

“Alexander is sponsoring a bill that would affect a few hundred Tennessee jobs as well. That’s regrettable. But the reasons behind the proposed ban make sense.

“Mountaintop mining destroys the mountains, and the waste from that practice affects streams and forests below the top of the mountain. It’s bad for the environment in so many ways. Yes, mountaintop mining creates jobs, but if those jobs are causing such irreparable harm, then why should we continue the practice that causes the problems?

“Miners in Kentucky, Ohio, West Virginia and Virginia are taking part in the protest, according to Roger Horton, director of Citizens for Coal, an advocacy group that organized the boycott. Horton said some 5,000 coal miners already have joined the boycott, which he hopes will spread to involve all of the nation’s 81,000 coal miners.

“‘He needs to mind his own business,’ Horton said of Alexander. ‘Why fool with us? We have good congressmen and senators here who know what’s best for West Virginia. We don’t need his interference.’

“What say you, Senator?

“‘Every year, millions of tourists come to Tennessee and spend millions of dollars to see our scenic mountaintops, not to see mountains whose tops have been blown off and dumped into streams,’ Alexander said. ‘I believe most Tennesseans agree that we should save our mountaintops.’

“In Logan County, W.Va., county administrator Rocky Adkins says he canceled a planned visit to Pigeon Forge this month. Adkins serves one of the nation’s largest coal-producing counties.

“We don’t want to lose anyone business, but neither do we want to perpetuate a bad practice. Miners work hard for a living, and the work is often dangerous. Alexander’s bill is not meant to punish them, but to protect the environment and stop an activity that damages streams and forests as well as views.

“If indeed miners boycott us and don’t come to see Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge and the Smokies, that’s too bad. But neither Sen. Alexander nor our community can be held hostage by people who make a living doing something that is so harmful. Alexander should remain tough in the face of such a threat and continue to push the legislation.”

Adkins, who made the comments to The Associated Press for a July 17 story that ran nationally, was not available for comment this morning before deadline.

A spokesperson for The Logan County Commission said Adkins was away on vacation, but not in Tennessee.

The Gatlinburg, Pigeon Forge and Sevierville areas are popular tourist destinations for many West Virginians, Adkins said in a recent phone interview with The Logan Banner. He said many of those West Virginians who like to spend their hard-earned dollars on vacation in east Tennessee are coal miners whose lives would be drastically affected if Alexander’s legislation is passed.

———

The Mountain Press Web site can be viewed at http://mountainpress.southernheadlines.com
comments (4)
« hallowfairy@mchsi.com wrote on Wednesday, Aug 05 at 11:17 AM »
I lived at Rum Creek-Logan, WV since I was 5 and until I moved out when married I was sick with this and that and earaches and thyroid and all this good stuff-and coal dust everywhere-and we had beautiful mountains - my siblings and I were in them every beautiful day from 3rd grade on until I left Logan-in my 20s-and then a few years ago-no years ago when we were in teens-the strip mines came in and that was it for the wandering in the woods-then a few years ago it was allowed for mountain top removal and look at all the chaos it has caused-flooding, tornadoes-winds coming in and getting caught in the valleys and destruction as bad as a tornado-and all the mudslides and all the damage to the scenic mountains-oh-wait-THERE ARE NONE NOW-and all the damage to the environment-and these will never be reclaimed-how can you rebuild on top of a mountain with all you have taken away-you know maybe you could - but considering all the years it took to MAKE them reclaim the strip mined areas - ha-it would never happen-and all this crap about the government in WV-that is a laugh and has been since before I was born-and I am 60 years old-graft and destruction in Logan was and is still rampant today--Yes, mines do create jobs-my dad was a miner for over 35 years and guess what he got for it-black lung and a small check - but I know of a few people who were never in the mines and got checks-for BLACK LUNG. Government was where?? Anyway-We were poor and all when growing up-but we made it-and we did not clear off the mountains-do like we did in my age-go where the jobs are-not where you have to destroy and cause environment damage let alone what it does to your health - other than what it does to the worker's health. My family would go collect coal along the tracks so we could have heat--NO THERE IS NOT A BEAUTIFUL MOUNTAIN TOP in WV - well, in LOGAN anymore-we come in for vists and want to leave as it is so horrible anymore and for beauty-where???? It is one of the dirtiest places we have ever been-animals still roam-litter is still everywhere-and trash everywhere-and trash cars everywhere and trash homes, trailers, yards-everywhere-I know there are other places the same way-but dang people have some pride and make others feel it too-where we live now-people take sections of roads and claim it and clean it-our rivers have clean ups on them all the time-people get out with canoes and clean - several times a year-toilets still run in the creeks and rivers in Logan-ugh.

Mountains now are bare and THEY ARE BARE-that is what greets visitors now-no trees-just bare land on top - no tall mountains - and this is just in the last 10 years-or less-it is not the most Beautiful Mountains anymore-it is a sad flat hill that greets people now-I feel depressed when I come there and realize how much people need jobs-but have to desecrate and really harm life for you and yours with all the environmental change--did anyone really tell the public-ok now-we will have flooding again-mudslides again-snow more than ever and tornadoes and winds like tornadoes-as you now do not have the shelter of the high mountains to protect you-how many people lost their homes, lives and family way of life because of mountain top removal so when it rained it all flooded- BIG TIME_??? how many ??? you cannot begin to imagine the destruction unless you have lived thru it-now tell me what this did to those people-yep THEY HAD JOBS-well, now they do not have homes,and some deaths and you know what-EXPECT MORE. EXPECT MORE AND WORSE - because government let mountain top mining happen. I encourage the Senator-finally someone that cares about life - where I live now it is flat-flat flat-and we long for the mountain view when we come home to visit but there is not a one in sight in The road into LOGAN, WV-for sure-and surrounding areas-because of greed for one thing as yeah-it was touted all over this is so good for the working person-but who really gets the money-not naming names - you know-but think about it-and really think what you have accomplished with MOUNTAIN TOP REMOVAL-again-just a few things to mention AGAIN-flood, tornados, mudslides, death, death, destruction. and NO BEAUTIFUL MOUNTAIN TOPS-NO THERE IS NOT-

« belcher12 wrote on Monday, Aug 03 at 09:22 PM »
let that us senator from there and the boob that wrote the comment come and pay our bills and put food on our tables and send our children to school. we have lived here for generations and generations and no one has complained till now i say let them freeze to death in the dark see how long they go will out electric and heat and hot meals. If you don't like wants going on here stay the heck out WV is a wondeerful place to visit and i wouldn't want to live anywhere else i have been to your state it's overpopulated and thought the some of the people are friendly i would not want to live there. so quit belly aching and leave us alone. The people of WV need to take a stank against all the epa groups and treehuggers and tell them we are doing just fine and we still have the most beautiful state mountaintop removal and all.
« roseharleymama wrote on Monday, Aug 03 at 07:24 PM »
you don't understand what is at stake for the

hard working people of wva you don't have to

worry about how you're going to feed your children or pay bills, you are in a tourist

enviroment and have no idea what you're talking

about stay of wva's state business
« dmcmudkips wrote on Friday, Jul 31 at 10:16 AM »
Maybe one of these days you people will understand that nobody important really cares about your boycotts.

Just like the article said, Tennessee will do fine without West Virginia's money. How do you like how this gets turned back around on you? How many times have you people told those that don't like WV's politics and coal mining practices "If you don't like it, take your money and go somewhere else?" Well now Tennessee is telling you the same thing.

North Carolina also introduced a similar bill. Are you going to boycott them too? I doubt it, because then none of you rednecks will be able to spend any money on NASCAR.

WEATHER
Sponsored by:



STOCK TICKER
Sponsored by:



featured businesses