Fatcow Icon
Represented correctly?
Jun 10, 2012 | 1357 views | 4 4 comments | 4 4 recommendations | email to a friend | print

Editor,

I was amused at the Hatfield and McCoy series, I believed it was filmed in Romania, certainly did not reflex the beautiful West Virginia Mountains, and the actor’s — for the most part — were not even American born. Neither could they pick up the Hillbilly slang or swagger.

The story was good, but I ‘m not too sure of all the truth of it. The trees in W.Va. are Beechnut, Hickory, Popular, Walnut, etc., not some old scrubs they showed cutting down in the movie.

I don’t feel West Virginia or Kentucky was represented correctly. But other than that, it was a pretty good flick.

Don Popp

Estherwood, La.



Comments
(4)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
formerloganres
|
July 06, 2012
I really enjoyed the Hatfields & McCoys on the History Channel. I thought that Kevin Costner did an excellent portrayal as did the others with speaking parts. I was disappointed it wasn't filmed on location using locals in the nonspeaking background roles some of whom are descendants of the families involved. I understand it was too expensive to film in the U.S. where it took place. Once again, films, products & etc. are made overseas because it is too expensive to produce them here. This has to end some time. Even still, I think it was excellent.
formerloganres
|
July 05, 2012
My friends & family really enjoyed the Hatfields & McCoys on the History Channel. I was disappointed the producers found it necessary to film in Romania. However, beyond that, it was great & Kevin Costner & all the actors who had speaking parts did an excellent job. The extras in non speaking roles were mainly Romanians so that was somewhat inconsequential except I am sure WV & Kentucky citizens would have appreciated the opportunity to perform & would have been great in light of the fact that many of the descendants still live in the area. But the producers felt it more economical to film oversees. You can't fault them. After all, everything else is produced overseas now. Sad to say.
AlienJohn
|
June 13, 2012
I am from Mingo County W.Va.

Yes, I grew up in them thar hills, and although I found the miniseries interesting I couldn't help but laugh at the obvious attempts to "sound" West Virginian when they failed so epically. There is no shortage of voice coaches available if one were to actually spend a couple days in the mountains. I think the movie could have been more authentic if they had. Thanks ya'll

John Booth Workman

Delbarton West By-God Virginia
AlexT
|
June 11, 2012
The History Channel's Hatfields and McCoys three-part mini-series was indeed filmed in Romania. They were looking for a "place that most resembled" West Virginia and Kentucky during that time and they felt that Romania was it. It wasn't about what trees grow in West Virginia, but rather the story.

I think if the actors tried to "sound" like West Virginians and Kentuckians did back then people would be offended. In reading the history of the two States, it was extremely hard to understand the people then.

Unfortunately, some people still look at West Virginians as being backward. As long as I have been here in Washington I still get teased about how long it took me to get used to wearing shoes. When people hear me talk and ask where I'm from, I ask them where they think I'm from. I get Pennsylvania or North Carolina, but never West Virginia. When I tell them where I'm from they are surprised.
Weather
Sponsored By:

Lottery
Sponsored By:

Stocks
Sponsored By:

Gas Prices
Sponsored By:

Featured Businesses
Recipes
Sponsored By: